You work from France for a US company, under a contract governed by the law of a US state, with your salary paid from the United States. This arrangement may appear straightforward until a restructuring, termination or request to regularise your employment situation raises questions.
Your employer’s location and the law stated in your contract do not, by themselves, determine your rights. Where you habitually work plays a central role. Three separate issues must be considered: the law governing your employment contract, the courts with jurisdiction and the applicable social security system.
For both employees and employers, reviewing these issues before a dispute arises can help secure the employment relationship.
Key Takeaways
- A US employment contract does not automatically exclude French employment protections. Where you habitually work is a key factor in determining which mandatory rules apply.
- An employee working habitually in France may be able to sue a US employer before a French employment tribunal, even if the company has no French subsidiary.
- Social security coverage must be assessed separately. Keeping an employee on US payroll does not, by itself, establish that US coverage remains appropriate.
- A US company can employ someone in France without creating a subsidiary, but must comply with the applicable employment and social security obligations.
Can You Keep a US Employment Contract While Working in France?
A contract governed by US law can remain in place, but it cannot necessarily exclude mandatory French employment protections.
Consider an employee hired in the United States who moves to France on a long-term basis with their employer’s agreement. They retain their role, attend meetings remotely and may develop a European client base. However, their contract and payroll arrangements remain organised as though they were still working in the United States.
The EU Rome I Regulation governs the choice of law for international employment contracts. Article 8 provides that this choice cannot deprive an employee of the mandatory protections of the law that would have applied without that choice.
The main connecting factor is the country in which, or from which, the employee habitually works. The actual working arrangements must therefore be examined, beyond the wording of the contract.
The Habitual Place of Work Is a Key Factor
Working from a home office in France on a long-term basis may establish France as the employee’s habitual place of work. A temporary stay for a limited assignment requires a different assessment.
An exception also applies where the circumstances as a whole show that the contract is more closely connected with another country. The court considers factors including tax, social security and professional arrangements. No single factor determines the outcome in every case.
The Court of Justice of the European Union addressed this assessment in its Schlecker judgment of 12 September 2013.
Regularising the arrangement therefore involves more than changing the contract’s title: its terms and the company’s practices must reflect the rules that actually apply.
Can You Bring a Claim Against a US Employer Before a French Employment Tribunal?
The absence of a French subsidiary does not necessarily prevent an employee from bringing proceedings in France.
Article 21 of the Brussels I Recast Regulation allows an employer based outside the European Union to be sued before the courts of the place where, or from where, the employee habitually works.
An employee who habitually works in France may therefore be able to bring a claim before the competent French court, depending on their circumstances.
Jurisdiction and applicable law remain separate questions. Bringing a claim before a French employment tribunal, known as the conseil de prud’hommes, does not automatically mean that every provision of French employment law will govern the contract.
Does an “At-Will” Clause Allow an Employer to Freely Dismiss an Employee Working in France?
An at-will clause cannot exclude mandatory French dismissal protections where the employee is entitled to benefit from them.
Many US contracts provide for at-will employment, allowing termination with considerable flexibility, subject to the restrictions imposed by the applicable US law.
Where French dismissal rules apply, the employer must consider the requirements concerning the grounds for dismissal, the procedure, notice and termination payments.
Announcing Termination During a Video Call Can Have Significant Consequences
An employer may believe that it can terminate the contract simply by telling the employee during a video call that their employment ends immediately.
Where this announcement demonstrates a definitive decision to dismiss, it may constitute a verbal dismissal. Under French law, an established verbal dismissal lacks a real and serious cause, the legal standard required to justify dismissal. The sequence of events and the words used are therefore crucial.
The French Court of Cassation has confirmed the consequences of a verbal dismissal, including in its judgment of 3 April 2024, case no. 23-10.931.
However, this must be distinguished from a procedural irregularity. Failing to hold a preliminary dismissal meeting does not, by itself, make every dismissal substantively unfair. Where valid grounds exist, the procedural breach may instead give rise to specific compensation under Article L. 1235-2 of the French Labour Code.
Which Social Security System Applies to an Employee Working in France?
Social security coverage must be assessed separately from the law governing the employment contract.
Where an employee falls within the French system, a foreign company without an establishment in France must make the relevant declarations and pay the corresponding contributions through Urssaf’s Foreign Firms Service.
Paying the employee’s salary from a US bank account does not remove these obligations.
Further information is available on Urssaf’s page for foreign employers without an establishment in France.
Temporary Assignments Are a Separate Case
The France–US Social Security Agreement allows an employee temporarily assigned to France to remain covered by the US system under certain conditions. This arrangement requires compliance with specific rules and a certificate confirming the applicable social security legislation.
Keeping the employee on US payroll or describing them as a “posted employee” in an exchange with HR is therefore insufficient. It is necessary to check whether the arrangement actually qualifies under the agreement.
The applicable procedure is explained by CLEISS for US employers temporarily assigning an employee to France.
What Should the Employee Check?
Incorrect social security arrangements can create difficulties concerning healthcare coverage, sickness benefits, pensions or unemployment benefits.
For each area of protection, the following points should be checked:
- The system under which the employee is covered.
- The declarations made by the employer.
- The contributions paid.
- The supporting documents available and any steps required to regularise the situation.
An irregularity does not automatically mean that the employee has no social security rights at all. Entitlements must be assessed with the relevant authorities according to the employee’s individual circumstances.
How Can You Prove That You Habitually Work in France?
Documents showing where and how you actually work are central to establishing your habitual place of work.
Useful evidence may include:
- The employer’s agreement to remote working from France.
- Exchanges with your manager or HR department.
- Documents showing your French address.
- Work calendars, business travel records and professional correspondence.
- Assignments carried out from France and communications with clients.
- Tax records and social security documents.
The aim is to establish a clear timeline: when did you begin working in France, under what conditions and with what knowledge on your employer’s part?
Documents should be retained in compliance with confidentiality and data protection requirements. Before using a recording or sensitive information, it is advisable to review its admissibility and conditions of use with a lawyer.
What Are the Risks for an Employer That Fails to Regularise the Arrangement?
The consequences depend on the obligations that apply and the breaches established. They may concern social security contributions, undeclared employment or the termination of the contract.
Social Security Contributions May Need to Be Regularised
Where the employee falls within the French system, failures to declare employment and pay contributions may result in contribution adjustments and applicable surcharges.
A foreign company should therefore identify the competent social security system when organising work from France.
Undeclared Employment May Be Established Under Specific Conditions
An affiliation error or failure to make a declaration does not automatically constitute undeclared employment, known in French law as travail dissimulé. In particular, the intentional nature of the breach must be established.
Where the legal conditions are met, the employee may be entitled, upon termination, to a fixed payment equivalent to six months’ salary under Article L. 8223-1 of the French Labour Code.
Termination May Lead to Litigation
Where French protections apply, an employee may claim payments relating to established breaches. Depending on the conditions governing each claim, these may include pay in lieu of notice, a dismissal indemnity or compensation for unfair dismissal.
However, a dismissal following a request to regularise employment is not automatically null and void. A claim for nullity requires a specific legal basis and evidence that the relevant conditions are met.
How Can a US Company Employ Someone in France?
Employing the Individual Directly Without Creating a Subsidiary
A US company can directly employ someone in France without setting up a French subsidiary.
Where the employee falls within the French social security system, the company must organise the relevant Urssaf formalities, social declarations and contribution payments. The Foreign Firms Service is intended for employers without an establishment in France.
This arrangement should also include a review of the employment contract, payroll and applicable employment rules.
Using an Employer of Record
An Employer of Record, or EOR, generally offers an arrangement under which a local entity becomes the employee’s legal employer while the employee works for the foreign company.
The commercial label “EOR” does not, by itself, guarantee that the arrangement complies with French law.
The legal framework must be checked. In principle, profit-making arrangements whose sole purpose is the supply of labour are prohibited in France, unless they fall within a statutory exception.
The French Ministry of Labour explains these restrictions in its guidance on unlawful labour lending.
Considering Portage Salarial Where the Assignment Is Suitable
Portage salarial is a regulated employment arrangement in which a professional provides services to a client through a portage company that employs them. It is intended for professionals with the necessary expertise, qualifications and autonomy.
A client company may use this arrangement for an occasional task outside its normal, permanent business activity, or for a specific assignment requiring expertise that it does not possess. An assignment with the same client company cannot exceed thirty-six months.
Portage salarial is therefore not a general solution for maintaining any existing employee role under unchanged working arrangements.
Further information is available in the French Ministry of Labour’s guidance on portage salarial.
What Should You Do If the Employment Relationship Is Already Underway?
Start by reviewing the contract alongside the actual working arrangements.
This includes the date the employee moved to France, the employer’s agreement, the duties performed, management arrangements, payroll and social security coverage.
This assessment helps identify the changes needed for the future and how the previous period should be addressed.
Signing a new contract does not, by itself, resolve any earlier obligations. The steps taken must account for length of service, remuneration already paid and any rights that may be affected.
If Employment Ends, Check the Time Limits Promptly
Under French law, a claim concerning termination must generally be brought within twelve months of notification of the termination. Other claims may be subject to different time limits.
In an international employment situation, the starting date and applicable limitation rules should be checked without waiting for discussions with the employer to conclude.
Securing an Employment Relationship Between France and the United States
Working from France for a US company requires coordination between the employment contract, working arrangements and social security coverage.
For employees, the priority is to identify the protections available and the steps they can take. For employers, it is to put suitable arrangements in place before a termination or inspection exposes difficulties.
Eve Domaniewicz advises employees working in France for foreign employers, as well as companies seeking to hire in France or regularise an existing arrangement. The firm assists with contract reviews, securing employment arrangements, negotiations and litigation.
Do you work in France for a US company, or employ someone in this situation?
Schedule an appointment now with Eve Domaniewicz’s law firm to discuss your circumstances.
