Your rights and options for negotiating your exit under French employment law
A merger, acquisition or change in leadership can significantly alter your position within a company. Two executive roles overlap, your team is combined with another department, or you start reporting to someone who was previously your peer.
Your title and salary remain unchanged, but your responsibilities are reduced. The company presents this as a natural consequence of the reorganisation. Do you have to accept it? Can you refuse? And how should you approach a potential exit negotiation?
Under French employment law, a genuine reduction in responsibilities may constitute a change to your employment contract requiring your consent. A change of reporting line alone, however, does not necessarily amount to a contractual change. Your duties before and after the reorganisation must be compared.
This article addresses employees whose situation is governed by French employment law. Corporate officeholders may be subject to different rules, particularly where they do not also hold a valid employment contract.
At a glance: what to do when your responsibilities are reduced
Before accepting the proposed role or discussing your departure:
- Request a written description of your future duties and reporting line.
- Compare your responsibilities, decision-making authority and autonomy before and after the reorganisation.
- Have any proposed contractual amendment reviewed before signing.
- Check the applicable response deadlines, particularly where the proposed change is based on economic grounds.
- Review your variable compensation and equity arrangements before agreeing on a departure date.
The aim is to identify what your employer can decide unilaterally, what requires your consent and which issues may be relevant to a negotiation.
Merger or acquisition: your employment contract remains in force
A change in ownership does not, by itself, allow the company to rewrite your duties.
In a share acquisition, the company employing you generally remains the same legal entity. Where the transaction involves a transfer falling within Article L. 1224-1 of the French Labour Code, existing employment contracts continue with the new employer.
The new organisational structure does not automatically override existing contractual commitments. The consequences for your employment must be assessed.
This is particularly relevant when two businesses combine their sales, finance, technical or HR functions. Having two directors covering the same function explains the organisational challenge; it does not determine either employee’s legal rights.
Combined roles or a new reporting line: when is your consent required?
A new reporting line is not automatically a demotion
You previously reported directly to the CEO and now report to a deputy managing director. Alternatively, your department becomes part of a larger function led by a former peer.
The employer may be entitled to make this change if your duties, professional classification and responsibilities are preserved.
The assessment must therefore look beyond the organisation chart:
- Who now sets the strategy for your function?
- Which teams do you continue to manage?
- Which budgets and projects remain under your control?
- Do you retain your delegated authority and autonomy?
- Has your role become primarily operational when it was previously strategic?
A genuine reduction in responsibilities may change your employment contract
Reducing your responsibilities or removing part of your duties may require your consent, even where your salary and job title remain unchanged.
The French Supreme Court confirmed this in a case following a corporate absorption. The reduction in responsibilities and removal of some duties amounted to a contractual change that the employee was entitled to refuse.
Retaining the employee’s title, classification coefficient and remuneration did not prevent the change from being contractual.
Reference: French Supreme Court, Employment Chamber, 9 November 2022, no. 21-13.066 — decision in French.
Illustrative example: a sales director previously responsible for strategy, team management and budgets keeps her title but becomes responsible for implementing another director’s decisions. The reduction in her autonomy and duties requires assessment, even without a salary reduction.
Removal from the executive committee must be considered in context
Removal from the executive committee — often referred to as the CODIR in French companies — is relevant, but does not necessarily establish a contractual change on its own.
It is necessary to assess whether it comes with reduced decision-making authority, the removal of strategic duties or a narrower remit.
The analysis considers the employment contract, the duties actually performed and the practical effects of the reorganisation.
Can you refuse a role with fewer responsibilities?
If the proposed change modifies your employment contract, your consent is required. Refusing that change is not, in itself, misconduct.
Your employer may abandon the proposal or consider dismissal. Any dismissal must have a valid legal basis and follow the applicable procedure. Your refusal alone is not sufficient justification.
By contrast, refusing a change that falls within the employer’s management powers may lead to disciplinary action. The legal nature of the proposal should therefore be assessed before you respond.
The French Ministry of Labour explains the distinction between contractual changes and changes to working conditions — guidance in French.
A response addressing the specific changes proposed is generally more useful than a blanket rejection of the reorganisation.
Changes proposed on economic grounds: check the response deadline
A specific procedure applies where an employer proposes changing an essential contractual term for one of the economic reasons recognised by French employment law.
Under Article L. 1222-6 of the French Labour Code, the proposal must be sent by registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt.
The period for notifying your refusal is:
- One month from receipt of the letter;
- Fifteen days where the company is in judicial reorganisation or liquidation proceedings.
Where this procedure is properly followed, failing to respond within the applicable period is treated as acceptance.
A merger, acquisition or change in leadership does not automatically constitute an economic reason within the meaning of the Labour Code.
Outside this specific procedure, silence does not automatically amount to acceptance. The legal framework of the proposal must be identified before drawing conclusions from a failure to respond.
The company wants you to stay: do you still have negotiating leverage?
The company may wish to retain your experience while offering you a narrower or less autonomous role.
Its wish to keep you does not resolve the legal issue: do the proposed duties require your consent?
If they do, several outcomes may be discussed:
- Keeping your existing duties;
- Agreeing on an acceptable redefined role;
- Negotiating a departure.
Your negotiating position depends on the actual changes, the available evidence, the reorganisation timetable and the legal risks associated with a potential termination.
There is no automatic entitlement to a negotiated exit or an enhanced severance package. A French individual mutual termination agreement, known as a rupture conventionnelle, requires both parties’ freely given consent. Your employer cannot be compelled to agree. Official French guidance
Interim management: how to document a reduction in your duties
The appointment of an interim manager may gradually change your role without an immediate written proposal.
Decisions start being made without you. Your team receives instructions from someone else. You are no longer involved in meetings or decisions previously falling within your remit.
Appointing an interim manager is not, in itself, unlawful. The issue is whether their involvement actually changes your responsibilities.
Useful documents may include:
- Your employment contract, amendments and job descriptions;
- Organisation charts before and after the changes;
- Delegations of authority or signing powers;
- Emails explaining the allocation of responsibilities;
- Records relating to your teams, budgets and projects;
- Written records of discussions about your role.
Focus on dated, specific and verifiable facts. Retaining and using professional documents must comply with the applicable rules on confidentiality and evidence.
Private equity acquisition: review your management package before negotiating
If you hold shares or benefit from equity incentives, the severance payment alone will not reflect the full financial implications of leaving.
The consequences depend on the instruments involved: free share awards, BSPCEs — a French share subscription warrant scheme — stock options, preference shares or other arrangements.
A review of your management package when leaving the company should cover:
- Vested and unvested rights;
- Exercise conditions and deadlines;
- Holding requirements or compulsory transfer obligations;
- Valuation mechanisms;
- The consequences of the reason for, and timing of, your departure.
Where Good Leaver or Bad Leaver provisions apply, their exact wording must be reviewed. A mutual termination agreement does not automatically secure favourable leaver status.
Employment and equity arrangements should be coordinated before any agreement is signed. Depending on the circumstances, this may require input from a corporate lawyer alongside employment counsel.
Mistakes to avoid before negotiating your departure
Resigning too quickly
Frustration or a perceived loss of status can make immediate resignation seem attractive.
It may weaken your negotiating position, affect your equity rights and, in principle, prevent immediate access to French unemployment benefits, subject to the applicable exceptions. French guidance on resignation and unemployment benefits
The consequences should be assessed before you give notice.
Signing an amendment without reviewing it
An attractive title or positive description may conceal a narrower role.
Check the duties, responsibilities and autonomy involved, together with the legal effect of the documents you are asked to sign.
Relying solely on verbal discussions
A senior manager may mention a potential departure during a meeting, only for the company’s position to change later.
A factual written follow-up can record what was discussed and request confirmation of the proposed changes. Its wording should remain measured and consistent with your strategy.
Naming a figure without a prior financial assessment
A request expressed only as a number of months’ salary may overlook variable compensation, equity, non-compete restrictions or the implications of the departure date.
Assessing the financial consequences of different departure scenarios provides a basis for comparing the employer’s offer with your legal and financial position.
How to prepare your exit negotiation
1. Review your position and define your objective
The review covers your contract, length of service, applicable collective bargaining agreement, actual duties and the proposed changes.
Any corporate office you hold must also be distinguished from your employment relationship. Membership of the executive committee does not, by itself, determine your legal status.
Your objective can then be defined: protecting your duties, agreeing on an acceptable role or preparing a negotiated departure.
2. Compare the financial consequences of the available options
The assessment should distinguish between sums already due, negotiable elements and potential claims dependent on litigation.
Relevant factors include the applicable reference salary, termination payments, departure timetable and equity rights.
Tax, social contributions and the implications for French unemployment benefits should also be considered.
3. Negotiate beyond the severance payment
Discussions may cover:
- The departure date and handover arrangements;
- The notice period or an agreed period of paid release from duties;
- Your bonus and variable compensation;
- Rights under your management package;
- Whether your non-compete clause will apply or be waived;
- Outplacement or other career transition support;
- Internal and external communications about your departure.
These elements should be considered together when assessing the overall terms of the agreement.
4. Choose and secure the appropriate legal framework
Depending on the circumstances, the options may include a rupture conventionnelle or a dismissal followed by a settlement agreement, known in French as a transaction.
These mechanisms serve different purposes. A settlement agreement resolves a dispute; it does not, by itself, terminate the employment contract.
Where economic grounds are involved, the applicable protections must also be compared. A mutual termination agreement must not be used to circumvent the protections attached to dismissal on economic grounds.
Further information is available in the official French guidance on individual mutual termination agreements.
Get advice before committing to a new role or departure
Has your role been duplicated following a merger or acquisition? Are you now reporting to another director with fewer responsibilities?
I advise executives and senior executives in Aix-en-Provence, Paris and remotely on proposed changes to their roles, the financial implications of leaving and the preparation of exit negotiations. Consultations are available in French and English.
Book an appointment with Eve Domaniewicz
